Learn how to invest

Month: January 2023

How To Calculate Stock Price in 3 Easy Ways

how to calculate stock price

Evaluating a stock can be a tedious task especially when you do not know where to start. In this article, I will show you how to calculate stock price in 3 easy ways.

There are a lot of ways how to do it and you can find them on the internet. Each of them is different a can get you very different results. However, there is nothing to worry about as you have to know what exactly they evaluate.

I will show you the basics of how to calculate stock price and determine which companies you should investigate further and which ones are better not to touch.

Why Do You Want To Evaluate a Stock Price?

If you are fairly new to investing you might be thinking that there is nothing to evaluate. If you like the company and you believe that it will grow then you should invest in it.

Well, from my personal experience, I would suggest that you do some research and give more time for your initial evaluation as you might be losing money on your poorly chosen strategy.

In the old beliefs that are now disproven companies are always selling at the correct value as it should be. So, basically, you see a price that the company is worth right now and you either buy it or don‘t.

This is not entirely true as people are not acting rationally all the time especially when they are scared or too greedy. Because of that stock prices may have altogether different values according to their intrinsic value. Intrinsic value means valuing a company based on its cash flow.

How To Calculate Stock Price?

Now that you know that you should check more than the face value of the company what should you really care about?

There are 3 main things that you should check to see if the company is interesting at the moment or not. These 3 things are a competitive advantage, ratios, and technical analysis.

1.     Competetive Advantage

moat

The first step in how to calculate stock price is checking if the company has a competitive advantage.

Competitive advantage often can be called a moat. Many investors suggest you consider it as a water-surrounding castle and protect it from intruders. This is exactly what a moat means – it protects the company from others stealing market share.

Low-cost and high-quality leader

Companies that have this kind of competitive advantage are big companies that can purchase their resources cheaply because of their buying power. The more company buys the better prices it can negotiate.

By doing this, companies can offer products cheaper and when there is a downturn in the market competitors might have to increase prices but a company with a low-cost moat can lower its gross profit and even grow going more market share. Thus creating a snowball effect.

Buying resources cheaply can also allow companies to offer higher quality products than other companies with similar prices as their expenses are lower.

The best way to find out if a company has this kind of competitive advantage is by visiting a company‘s website or comparing companies in the same industry with free online tools like finviz.

A company like Costco definitely has this competitive advantage as it has 847 stores in the world as of 2023 January and their revenue last year was 222.7 billion USD. Imagine quoting a price from a supplier for a few million items each month when competitors have a lot smaller demand. Of course, Costco gets the best price.

Known Brand

Known brand competitive advantage is achieved when a company is established in its market. In fact, it is more like when you think of a product and one particular brand comes to mind.

For example, if you think of a smartphone, who has not heard of Apple‘s iPhone? If it is a beverage drink then everybody thinks of Cola. And if it is coffee then there is probably no American who at least does not know that Starbucks exists and how they always misspell your name on the cup.

There are a lot of different reasons why a company can achieve this. Still, in most cases, it is because of very aggressive marketing to the point that Pampers brand has become a noun in people‘s minds or the company changed the market with its innovation.

Other moats

The moats mentioned above are the most common. Some include switching, network effect, toll bridge, and secret.

For more information about moats, I suggest you read my other article Investment checklist by ‘Invested‘.

2.     Ratios

When you have established that the company has a moat you have to ask how to calculate stock price. That means checking how it is doing financially compared to others. A lot of different ratios can be found online that can help you do that. I will go through the most important ones.

Price To Earning Ratio (P/E)

The best-known ratio out there is the price-to-earning ratio (P/E). You can find this ratio almost everywhere. The P/E ratio is calculated by dividing a stock price by the company‘s most recent earnings per share (EPS). EPS is calculated by dividing the company’s profits by its outstanding shares.

To put it simply, the P/E ratio shows how much investors are willing to pay for the company’s earnings. In general, it is said that it is good if a company has a ratio below 25. However, it highly depends on the industry average.

I suggest you read more about 11 Stock Market Sectors.

Price To Sales Ratio (P/S)

Price to sales ratio (P/S) is a very good metric that shows how well a company is growing when it does not have huge profits yet. The P/S ratio is calculated by dividing its outstanding share by its annual revenue.

A good example of this would be to evaluate Amazon. As it is a huge company it grows very fast because it keeps profits low.

Generally, if this ratio is below 2 then the company is doing great. However, like with the P/E ratio you have to compare it to the industry‘s average.

You can easily find these metrics in Yahoo Finance and investing.com. Generally, I check financial information from Yahoo Finance, but investing.com shows you industry averages of these ratios in one place.

Price To Book Ratio (P/B)

Price to book ratio shows the company‘s book value per share. It‘s calculated by dividing book value by outstanding shares.  A company‘s book value is calculated as assets minus liabilities.

This ratio is best used for companies that have a lot of assets like banks and financial institutions.

Generally, you want to ratio to be below 1 but you have to compare it to industries average ratio.

To find out more about ratios I suggest reading Investment checklist by ‘Invested‘.

3.     Technical Analysis

The third step on how to calculate stock price I wanted to mention is technical analysis. Technical analysis is often referred to as studying graphs and trends of stock prices.

This method is used to identify good trading opportunities by evaluating the stock‘s past performance indicators. Mostly, this analysis is used by day traders or short-term investors.

Personally, I love numbers and it is fun for me to analyze statistics and trends but when it comes to investing I lean more toward value investing principles that Benjamin Graham, Warren Buffer, and Peter Lynch suggest.

By this thinking it can be more worthwhile to concentrate on doing the fundamental analysis of a company and not care as much for the current technology trends as over 10 years period it makes practically no difference at all.

That being said I also do not like to see my investment going down as soon as I purchase it and see it staying the same or dropping for 1 or 2 years.

Candles and Moving Average

When you do a technical analysis I would suggest using Investing.com or Yahoo Finance which already has all the tools you will need for it.

There are 2 main things you should look for when you look for a good time to invest.

Candles

Always change the graph to candles. Green candles mean that the price went up, and red means it went down. The length of the candle shows how much the price has changed over a set period of time. I would suggest using a day for a time interval.

Moving Average

Also, you want to add a moving average to the graph for the whole thing to make sense to you so you could start analyzing. It shows what was the average price for a set period of time. If you use a day interval I suggest setting it to 14 days. By default, investing.com is set to 9.

appl candle graph
Source: investing.com

In the chart above I market all the things, you should press to set the graph to get the same view as me.

The moving average is crossing the red candle from below – once this happens stock price is supposed to start moving down. It means that the current up moving is slowing and it may start going down. You can see it on the left side.

The moving average is crossing the green candle from above – once this happens stock price is supposed to start moving up. It means that the current down moving is slowing and it may start going up. You can see it on the right side.

According to technical analysis, these are the 2 points when you should be buying and selling your investment.

Down Side of Day Trading

If you are using only technical analysis then you will likely be buying and selling all the stocks every day. This requires a lot of your attention and time. Not to say that you will probably be tired from it and it could be hard on you mentally.

When you do trading every day you will actually be gaining or losing money often. Can you really bear it?

You also have to keep in mind that when day trading you will be paying additional costs upon purchase and selling. Moreover, you will have to pay taxes as you gain profit. Whereas with value investing you can hold stocks till the day you want to cash out.

If you want to try though I suggest you do it on an app like Revolut or a similar program that will lower your expenses to almost zero until you want to take the money out to your bank account.

Conclusion On How To Calculate Stock Price

  • 3 steps to evaluate stocks are moats, ratios, and technical analysis
  • Moats help companies in bad market situations
  • Ratios let you know if the current stock price is overvalued
  • Technical analysis helps you determine where the stock price is going in a concise period

Don’t miss new articles by subscribing!

11 Stock Market Sectors

Stock market sectors

At first, when you start analyzing stocks it can be very daunting when you see that you can buy over 8000 different stocks and many index funds. It can be hard to separate or compare stocks with each other without stock market sectors.

What is Stock Market Sectors?

Stock market sectors are called Global Industry Classification Standard (GICS). It was created by Standard & Poor‘s (S&P) and Morgan Stanley Capital International. This classification helps analyze businesses by their main activity in the market.

Stock Market Sectors classification helps both individual and professional investors to build their portfolios in a diversified manner.

For any investors, it is a good idea to own stocks from every of the stock market sectors. Of course, if you are just starting out it can be a lot easier to purchase an index fund that helps you manage the risks.

I recommend reading more about it in my article about Index Funds.

S&P 500 Stock Market Sectors

When talking about stock market sectors it is easier to understand them by analyzing the biggest companies. That can be done by looking up the ones that belong to the S&P 500 index fund.

From the table below you can see that 3 sectors dominate this index fund thus these companies are the largest in the US. Those companies belong to the technology, healthcare, and financial services sectors.

The technology sector is cyclical, meaning it performs best when the overall market is growing. Whereas healthcare and financial services sectors are more conservative sectors that usually perform well even when the market faces a downturn compared to other sectors.

As with any investment portfolio S&P 500 index fund is a good example of a diversified portfolio where it has some good companies that grow in good years and the ones that prevent you from devastating losses in the down years.

Sectors size
Data Source: finviz.com, Source: Author

A very important aspect of stock market sectors is determining whether they are overvalued or not at the moment. In the table below you can see that by 10 years of data everything that is above 100% is overvalued and below that everything is undervalued.

Of course, this is not conclusive, but it is a good indicator. Moreover, stock market sectors can be very large so some companies in it can be overvalued and others can be undervalued.

P/E ratio by sectors
Data source: gurufocus.com, Source: ‘Is The Stock Market Overvalued

1. Technology Sector

The technology sector is the biggest one. In this sector, you can find companies that are developing technological items or services, everything that is related to computers, microprocessors, and operating systems.

Companies in the technology sector are highly competitive and are driven to make innovations to stay in their positions. When the market is growing these companies make huge plans, make new stuff, and try to sell them as fast as possible, however, as soon as the crisis hits these companies fall the most and cut back on new innovations during the recession period.

You can already see that Apple and Google are letting people go and are cutting back on new innovations.

Overall the market cap is 12.19T USD, there are a total of 792 being traded globally, and there are 71 companies in the S&P 500 index fund.

S&P 500 companies in this sector grew a total of 376.33% over the past 10 years (37.63% average annual return).

  • Typically cyclical – most companies do better when the market is rising and falls hard when a recession hits.
  • Performs better when the economy is growing
  • Growth companies – most companies are still small and usually can get you very high returns.
  • High P/E ratio – Compared to other sectors it is ridiculously high because of people’s expectations.

The biggest companies are Apple Inc. (AAPL), Microsoft Corporation (MSFT), NVIDIA Corporation (NVDA), Broadcom Inc. (AVGO), and Cisco Systems Inc. (CSCO).

2. Healthcare Sector

The healthcare sector is the second largest. It consists of companies that supply medical items, pharmaceutical companies, and scientific-based companies.

Companies from this sector in the US get support from the government as there is a huge demand for it from the Baby Boomer generation.

Companies that produce medicine, and medical appliances usually have a good moat (Read an article about Investment Checklist by ‘Invested’ to understand it better), so typically they can do better when the market is going down than companies from other sectors.

Overall the market cap is 7.85T USD, there are a total of 1309 being traded globally, and there are 66 companies in the S&P 500 index fund.

S&P 500 companies in this sector grew a total of 218.07% over the past 10 years (21.81% average annual return).

  • Non-cyclical – healthcare sector is considered crucial and both people and the US government spend money on it regardless of the market situation.
  • Hard entry – Every drug requires several years to be developed and after that, they are protected by patents.
  • Economy of scale – big companies can buy needed materials at lower costs because of their buying power.
  • Research and development – it requires a lot of money in the first place to start a company in this sector.

The biggest companies are UnitedHealth Group Incorporated (UNH), Johnson & Johnson (JNJ), Eli Lilly and Company (LLY), Merck & Co. Inc. (MRK), and AbbVie Inc. (ABBV).

3. Financial Services Sector

Financial companies are considered the ones that work with finance, investing, and the ones that store or move money.

This sector is the pillar of the world’s economy as it controls how money is flowing. When this sector is strong it can drive high growth in the market whereas a weak sector can be a cause of a market crisis.

When unemployment rises, consumers lower their spending. Because of that central banks lower interest rates and encourage spending for the market to get back up.

Currently, banks are doing the exact opposite and are increasing interest rates and with that, they are trying to stop spending as the market is highly overvalued. Thus they are trying to prevent probably the biggest market crash in history.

Overall the market cap is 8.23T USD, there are a total of 3594 being traded globally, and there are 70 companies in the S&P 500 index fund.

S&P 500 companies in this sector grew a total of 153.51% over the past 10 years (15.35% average annual return).

  • Credit card companies may shrink during recessions
  • Mortgage companies may benefit from low-interest rates
  • Overall relatively stable

The biggest companies are Berkshire Hathaway Inc. Class B (BRK.B), JPMorgan Chase & Co. (JPM), Visa Inc. Class A (V), Mastercard Incorporated Class A (MA), and Bank of America Corp (BAC).

4. Consumer Cyclical Sector

You can think about the consumer cyclical sector as companies that sell luxury items or services. Companies in this sector perform best in growing markets as people are willing to spend more money on things that are for pleasure rather than necessity.

How many subscriptions to streaming services do you currently have? If it is more than one it is good to tell that we have money to spend right now and the consumer cyclical sector is booming. However, once people start to think about where their money is going this sector will be one of the first to lose its value.

In general, this sector together with the technology sector does well when the market is growing and crashes hard when we face a crisis.

Overall the market cap is 6.86T USD, there are a total of 579 being traded globally, and there are 58 companies in the S&P 500 index fund.

S&P 500 companies in this sector grew a total of 172.23% over the past 10 years (17.22% average annual return).

  • Cyclical companies – like other cyclical companies this sector can yield the highest returns when the market is rising and it falls the most of all when the market is crashing.

The biggest companies are Amazon.com Inc. (AMZN), Tesla Inc (TSLA), Home Depot Inc. (HD), McDonald’s Corporation (MCD), and NIKE Inc. Class B (NKE).

5. Industrials Sector

The industrial sector is quite wide as there are airline, railroad, and even military weapons manufacturing companies.

Companies that belong to this category mainly produce goods used in manufacturing, resource extraction, and construction.

Overall the market cap is 5.42T USD, there are a total of 649 being traded globally, and there are 71 companies in the S&P 500 index fund.

S&P 500 companies in this sector grew a total of 146.17% over the past 10 years (14.62% average annual return).

  • Cyclical companies – these companies do better when the market is rising overall.

The biggest companies are Raytheon Technologies Corporation (RTX), Honeywell International Inc. (HON), Caterpillar Inc. (CAT), Union Pacific Corporation (UNP), and United Parcel Service Inc. Class B (UPS).

6. Communication Services Sector

In this sector, companies try to keep people connected. These companies are internet providers, cell service providers, media, entertainment, and so on.

In short, these companies transmit words in voice, words, audio, or video. The biggest problem for this sector is keeping up with people’s need for faster data connectivity and better quality overall.

Overall the market cap is 4.19T USD, there are a total of 289 being traded globally, and there are 25 companies in the S&P 500 index fund.

S&P 500 companies in this sector grew a total of 16.99% over the past 10 years (1.7% average annual return).

  • Depending on the company can be defensive or cyclical – you have to go deeper and analyze all the companies in this sector to find the ones that can contain their growth even in down years.
  • Overall a sector that has everything – you can find defensive, cyclical, and growth companies in this sector.

The biggest companies are Alphabet Inc. Class A (GOOGL), Alphabet Inc. Class C (GOOG), Meta Platforms Inc. Class A (META), Walt Disney Company (DIS), and Verizon Communications Inc. (VZ).

7. Consumer Defensive Sector

These are the essential companies that provide us with our everyday items like food, beverages, household, and personal items.

Consumer defensive companies have an advantage in crisis years as consumers are not willing to cut on their essential needs. Tabaco companies can also be found in this category.

Overall the market cap is 4.16T USD, there are a total of 248 being traded globally, and there are 36 companies in the S&P 500 index fund.

S&P 500 companies in this sector grew a total of 102.44% over the past 10 years (10.24% average annual return).

  • Does better in crisis situations – when inflation occurs these companies can simply increase their prices without losing customers.
  • Outperforms S&P 500 index fund in down years
  • Dividends – a lot of companies pay out dividends
  • Slow growth – there is no stimulus for this sector to achieve significant growth like in other sectors.

The biggest companies are Procter & Gamble Company (PG), PepsiCo Inc. (PEP), Coca-Cola Company (KO), Costco Wholesale Corporation (COST), and Walmart Inc. (WMT).

8. Energy Sector

Energy sectors consist of companies that provide oil, gas, and other kinds of fuel, as well as companies that gather these materials. This also includes renewable energy.

In 2021 the US promised 550B USD in investments in the energy industry which will stimulate its growth in the next few years.

Overall the market cap is 3.75T USD, there are a total of 265 being traded globally, and there are 23 companies in the S&P 500 index fund.

S&P 500 companies in this sector grew a total of 21.65% over the past 10 years (2.17% average annual return).

  • Sensitive to economic changes – demand is dependent on the overall market and political events.
  • Sensitive to supply-demand trends – when oil and gas prices rise this sector earns more and vice versa.

The biggest companies are Exxon Mobil Corporation (XOM), Chevron Corporation (CVX), ConocoPhillips (COP), Schlumberger NV (SLB), and EOG Resources Inc. (EOG).

9. Utilities Sector

Utility companies similar to the consumer Defensive sector provide us with necessary stuff for homes and offices like electricity, water, and gas.

On economic downturns, Utilities sectors perform well as when everything is crashing this sector still generates returns as usual.

Overall the market cap is 1.62T USD, there are a total of 114 being traded globally, and there are 30 companies in the S&P 500 index fund.

S&P 500 companies in this sector grew a total of 96.26% over the past 10 years (9.63% average annual return).

  • Crisis proof – utilities are essential for well-being, so these companies can raise prices when they have more expenses and customers will still use their services.
  • Pays dividends – as most companies are already established and do not produce high growth they tend to pay out dividends
  • Low returns – with high-interest rates it can be more profitable to choose bonds as their prices might get you better returns.
  • Regulated by the government – these companies are usually controlled or regulated and cannot produce high returns.

The biggest companies are NextEra Energy Inc. (NEE), Duke Energy Corporation (DUK), Southern Company (SO), Dominion Energy Inc (D), and Sempra Energy (SER).

10. Real Estate Sector

This sector is quite new. You can find companies that pay as high as 90% of their profits as dividends.

The real estate sector includes companies that work in residential, commercial, industrial, raw land, and special use categories. Purchasing land or property is also calculated as real estate sector investment, as well as investing via REIT.

Overall the market cap is 1.45T USD, there are a total of 270 being traded globally, and there are 31 companies in the S&P 500 index fund.

S&P 500 companies in this sector grew a total of 25.42% over the past 5 years (5.08% average annual return).

  • Does not correlate with stocks – this sector is only affected when companies are not willing to put money into expanding. Naturally when the market is booming this sector grows faster.
  • Usually pays dividends – some of the companies are well established and do not expect to grow as fast. They try to attract investors with dividends.
  • Considered safe – in general real estate is regarded as a safe investment that is constantly gaining in value. Historically there were very few crises when this market experienced a downturn.

The biggest companies are Prologis Inc. (PLD), American Tower Corporation (AMT), Equinix Inc. (EQIX), Crown Castle Inc. (CCI), and Public Storage (PSA).

11. Basic Materials Sector

Basic materials sectors provide the raw materials for other sectors to function like gold, zinc, copper, and wood.

Materials gathered and processed in this sector are used in pretty much every other sector.

Overall the market cap is 2.54T USD, there are a total of 256 being traded globally, and there are 22 companies in the S&P 500 index fund.

S&P 500 companies in this sector grew a total of 108.54% over the past 10 years (10.85% average annual return).

  • Performs best when the market is growing – basic materials are mostly needed when the market is growing. Because of that companies in this sector are also considered cyclical.

The biggest companies are Linde plc (LIN), Air Products and Chemicals Inc. (APD), Freeport-McMoRan Inc. (FCX), Sherwin-Williams Company (SHW), and Corteva Inc (CTVA).

Conclusion

  • There are 11 investing sectors
  • Cyclical stocks are: Technology, Consumer Cyclical, Industrials, Basic Materials, Communication Services, Energy
  • Defensive stocks are: Healthcare, Financial Services, Consumer Defensive, Utilities, Real estate
  • Over the last 10 years technology (376.33%) and healthcare (218.07%) sectors grew the most.
  • You should always diversify your portfolio!

Don’t miss new articles by subscribing!

Passive Investing With Index Funds

Index funds

How much time are you willing to put into investing? Do you have any knowledge about investing? Do you have time to learn? If these questions make you uneasy then index funds might the best investment option for you.

With index funds, all you need is make some research at first and then you can start investing on autopilot.

Sounds too good to be true? Then keep reading and find out for yourself.
What is an Index Fund?

An index fund is considered an investment fund, a mutual fund of an exchange-traded fund (ETF). An index fund consists of a lot of stocks put together for you to buy.

These funds are not actively managed. So, the expenses are far less than the actively managed fund. This is great because a fund operates on a set of rules that actively managed fund does not follow. Because of that human emotion has very little impact on the decision of what should be put into these funds.

However, index funds do not stay the same. As some companies rise and some fall index fund changes their package as well. For example, the most popular index fund is the S&P 500 which consists of the 500 biggest US stocks.

If a company loses its position as a top 500 company it gets sold by S&P 500 index fund.

1. Why Index Funds are Popular?

Index funds are very popular because they consist of a lot of companies that provide lower risks. It does not require as much knowledge as investing in the stock market. So, beginners love these kinds of funds.

However, not only beginners should be interested in index funds. Even Warren Buffet said that most people should avoid stocks and invest in an index fund.

  • Market average returns – over a long period of time only a handful of mutual funds that are actively managed perform better than index funds. However, many people try to beat the market. You can find a lot of books about people who tried and succeeded. On the other hand, there are at least 90% more people who performed a lot worse than the S&P 500 index fund over 20 year period.
  • Diversification – investing in an index fund is like investing in 500 or more companies at the same time. For many investors, it is very hard to invest in 500 companies by themselves. Mostly because you need a lot of money to do it and you will pay a lot more taxes when you purchase and later sell that many companies. Index funds let you diversify a lot better.
  • Low risk – because of diversification you instantly lower your risk to market fluctuations in different sections. You should know that the risk still exists and index funds have lost 50% of their value a few times over the last 100 years. However, it rose a lot more.
  • Cheap entry – depending on the index fund and where you purchase index funds you can do it a lot more cheaply than investing in mutual funds. Index funds usually have less than 1% of fees. Not to mention that a lot of index fund shares that mimic the S&P 500 index fund right now cost around 400 USD.
  • Tax efficient – index funds only required you to buy and hold them. When with stocks you always have to make new purchases and sell some positions when they are no longer attractive with their balance sheet.
  • Passives investing – how much is there to do when you invest in index funds? After you have done your initial analysis and chosen where you want to invest there can be absolutely zero to do. You can even auto-invest each month if you want. So, you can avoid all the hassle.

2. The Smartest Investment Book You‘ll Ever Read

How many books have you read on investing in the stock market and beating it? I have read a few, and some of them are interesting, but have you ever read a book about investing in index funds?

The book ‘The Smartest Investment Book You‘ll Ever Read‘ by Daniel R. Solin does exactly that.

He has some interesting take on the kinds of investing and in a lot of cases I believe what he writes. He encourages you to diversify your index fund portfolio in 4 parts.

  • Total Canadian stock index fund
  • S&P 500 following index fund
  • EFA index fund (Europe, Australia, Asia, and Far East total market)
  • Total bond index fund

In what proportions you should own it depends on your risk level. To put it simply it depends on your age left till pension, your ability to increase your salary, and so on. The main thing that is different is that the less risk you are willing to take the more you should invest in bond index funds.

In this book, you can find a quiz that helps you determine what risk rating you apply according to your finances.

I did my personal analysis on these index funds and I believe they are very much diversified, however, the return is not that great. Only the US market‘s index funds can get you around 9% average annual growth.

Index funds from other countries do not perform that well and their average is half the US index funds. Moreover, bond index funds were doing terribly for the last 10 years. However, this might change when the crisis happens.

3. Types of Index Funds

There are a lot of different index funds out there and it can be hard to choose one or a few of them. I would classify them into 6 categories (at least the main ones) and then the choice is really yours depending on your location and current market situation.

The location is important because since 2017 European citizens cannot purchase US index funds directly because the US disagrees to provide required documentation about index funds that are not required in the US. You can read more about it on investopedia.com.

When I say that the market situation matters I mean that there are a lot of similar ETFs that follow the same indexes. You should choose the one that you trust the most, the one that has the most sales and purchases, and the one that has the lowest taxes.

S&P 500 Following Index Funds

There are a lot of index funds that follow the S&P 500 to choose from. For example, I purchased iShares Core S&P 500 ETF (IVV) (average annual return over 10 years is 12.53%) because it was the most traded index fund in Europe that tracks this index.

iShares Core S&P 500 ETF (IVV)
Data source: finance.yahoo.com

People in America have other good options like Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (VOO)
(average annual return over 10 years is 12.54%). I believe these are the ETFs that are essential in your portfolio.

Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (VOO)
Data source: finance.yahoo.com

These funds are considered safer than others since they represent the biggest US companies that have been around for a long time. This is what investors usually are looking for.

Total Stock Market Funds

If however, you want to earn exactly as much as the whole market performs you can choose total stock market funds like Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Admiral Shares (VTSAX) (Average annual return over 10 years is 11.66%) that tracks all the US market.

Vanguard Total Stock Market Index Admiral Shares (VTSAX)
Data source: finance.yahoo.com

Another option would be Vanguard Total World Stock Index Fund (VT) (Average annual return over 10 years is 8.35%) which consists of pretty much every share from around the world. However, it gets you fewer returns.

Vanguard Total World Stock Index Fund (VT)
Data source: finance.yahoo.com

These funds are good for you if you believe that smaller companies that are not on the top 500 list will do better. Thus your returns would be higher.

Small-cap Value Index Funds

These funds typically are traded at a low price compared to their performance. In a sense, they follow the value investing principles. Vanguard Small-Cap Value Index Fund (VSIAX) (Average annual return over 10 years is 9.89%) is one of them.

Vanguard Small-Cap Value Index Fund (VSIAX)
Data source: finance.yahoo.com

Another similar fund is Fidelity Small Cap Enhanced Index Fund (FCPEX) (Average annual return over 10 years is 10.91%).

Fidelity Small Cap Enhanced Index Fund (FCPEX)
Data source: finance.yahoo.com

Value index funds have less volatility but offer you fewer returns. So, you could consider them a safer investment.

Small-cap Growth Index Funds

Growth funds are best when the market is rising but a lot worse when the market dips. These funds have higher fluctuation so they are considered riskier. Vanguard Growth ETF (VUG) (Average annual return over 10 years is 12.92%) is one of the biggest growth funds.

. Vanguard Growth ETF (VUG)
Data source: finance.yahoo.com

iShares Russell 1000 Growth ETF (IVF) (Average annual return over 10 years is 13.9%) performed even better than the Vanguard fund.

iShares Russell 1000 Growth ETF (IVF)
Data source: finance.yahoo.com

These funds are built so they would do well in good times. The downside is that you have to get off the train early not to lose your money in the process.

International Stock Funds

International funds can provide you with more diversification from the US stock market. There are more risks with other markets as they are more volatile and it can be hard to predict returns of other countries as in general the whole market does not grow as fast as the US market but if you niche down to one region or one country that country start growing and give you better returns.

An example of an international fund can be Vanguard Developed Markets Index Fund Admiral Shares (VTMGX) (Average annual return over 10 years is 4.82%).

Vanguard Developed Markets Index Fund Admiral Shares (VTMGX)
Data source: finance.yahoo.com

Fidelity International Index Fund (FSPSX) (Average annual return over 10 years is 4.82%) is another example.

Fidelity International Index Fund (FSPSX)
Data source: finance.yahoo.com

You can find a lot of different index funds that have very different returns when you consider international index funds.

Bond Index Funds

When investing in these funds you are investing in US treasury bonds, agency bonds, corporate bonds, and so on. These index funds provide you with safe investments that are guaranteed by the US government. Volatility is quite low in these funds, however, returns are also not as high. These funds really shine in the market crashes providing you with returns when stocks tend to go down.

One of the examples is Fidelity U.S. Bond Index Fund (FXNAX) (Average annual return over 10 years is 0.99%).

Fidelity U.S. Bond Index Fund (FXNAX)
Data source: finance.yahoo.com

Another example is Vanguard Total Bond Market Index Fund (VBTLX) (Average annual return over 10 years is 1.13%).

Vanguard Total Bond Market Index Fund (VBTLX)
Data source: finance.yahoo.com

These funds really shine in the market crashes providing you with returns when stocks tend to go down. Since there was no real crash in the last 10 years returns were not great in this category.

4. How to Purchase Index Funds?

Once you know what types of index funds there are you should investigate them further and shorten your list. It might be a good idea to choose the best index funds from the 6 categories I have mentioned before and add them to your wishlist.

Before You Buy

  • You should analyze what kind of expenses you will have to pay when buying, selling, and annually.
  • Are there any particular risks with this fund?
  • What index fund follows?
  • Does the index fund‘s strategy hand in hand with my goals?

When you do your analysis and chose index funds you like you must pick the best place to purchase these funds.

Where To Buy?

Your bank – My bank gives me quite good terms when buying index funds. For example, I pay 11 EUR for a purchase no matter how much I buy. This is quite good for me as there are no other expenses included and I do not have to make any additional transactions.
Index fund company – A lot of index fund issuers sells their index funds themselves. However, if you choose to diversify between different companies it can be quite annoying for you to transfer your money. Also, some companies have minimum purchase limits that prevent new investors from making their first purchases.
• Broker – You can find yourself a broker that can do everything for you. However, keep in mind that he or she will probably charge you when doing a purchase or selling indexes. On the flip side usually, they can purchase every index fund no matter where you live.
Third-party online brokerage company – There are some companies that act like a broker, however, they have their own website where you can do everything yourself. Of course, there are some costs included depending on the company.

I have tried interactivebrokers.com. They offer amazingly low investing fees compared to others. However, I found them hard to use and left a bad review when I couldn‘t buy S&P 500 and other US index funds. Only later I found out I could not buy them because I live in Europe (Sorry, interactivebrokers!).

This is an important step, do not skip it! Once you have your wishlist and you know where to buy index funds all there is left to do is figure out your diversification plan and prepare yourself for what you would do if the index fund would drop in value.

5. Why You Should Not Own Index Funds?

Although buying index funds is recommended by a lot of famous people like Warren Buffet right now might not be the best time to start investing.

  • Highly affected by market fluctuations and crashes – the downside of index funds is that when the market goes down your investment takes a hit because index funds represent the market. When you pick your own stocks you can choose companies that should do well if the market crash happens.
  • Not flexible – you will have to own even the stocks that you do not want to. Whereas with stocks you have full power to make these decisions for yourselves.
  • No human interaction – index funds are preprogrammed. This means that even if you would have some information that one company is doing poorly and is likely to lose value the index would not do anything about it.
  • Limited returns – You can only return what is the market average and you cannot outperform it. So your income is fixed on average 9% annual returns.
  • The stock market is overvalued – In my previous article ‘Is The Stock Market Overvalued‘ I have proven that the stock market currently is overvalued with the help of some market indicators.

Conclusion

The advantages of investing in index funds are undeniable. However, like with every other investment, there are some risks that you need to evaluate. Here is a checklist if you want to start investing in index funds.

  • Add 6 index funds to your wishlist from each category
  • Choose the best place to buy them from
  • Determine if it is a good time to buy them
  • Decide on a diversification strategy
  • Prepare what you would do if an index fund would lose its value

Don’t miss new articles by subscribing!

Investment checklist by ‘Invested‘

Investment checklist

If you want to learn how to invest but do not like to read books I recommend reading only this book ‘Invested‘ by Danielle Town and Phil Town. ‘Invested‘ was probably the most influential book on me that I have ever read. Not to mention the most interesting book about investing.

Most books about investing usually contain a lot of examples than not always are interesting. However, this book tells a story about how Danielle hated numbers, and hated investing, yet learned to be proficient in it in one year.

This book also helps you to build an investment checklist that you can use for all of your investments.

About Danielle and Phil Towns

The story revolves around daughter and father – Danielle and Phil with occasional mentions of Warren Buffer and Charlie Munger.

Danielle was a lawyer but was stressed out by the job and was keeping herself functioning with the help of medication. This was the main driver of why she wanted to change her profession.

Right now Danielle has her own website dannieletown.com in which you can find her blog and a lot of useful information.

Phil Town was an investor for a long time and has written a few of his own books. He was teaching others and decided to help Danielle to learn investing. You can find more information about him on his website ruleoneinvesting.com.

Alternatives to stock investments

As Daniele hated investing and wanted to do nothing close to it she explored all the other options before she finally tried investing in stocks.

A few of the options:

Inflation effect on savings

If you keep your money in your safe, bank account, a sock, or anywhere without it being invested – you lose money.

Purchasing power
Source: calculator.net

Average annual inflation for the last 30 years is 2.3%. This means that if you kept your money in your bank account for 30 years it would lose 50% of its value due to inflation.

Every other option than losing money is better than doing nothing with it.

Mutual funds

Mutual funds are a terrible investment for most people:

  • High entry price – 250.000 USD
  • They get paid even if they lose money
  • You pay for the privilege of working with a hedge fund

They charge you 3% plus you have to include 2.3% of inflation. In total it is 5.3% gone. What is worse is that they get paid even if they lose money.

They are still valid because most 401k requires to be invested in mutual funds. Other than that they should not exist at all and I believe the system will change eventually.

Market index funds

One of the options that were deemed as bad in the book was market indexes. Personally, I disagree with this and I think Warren Buffet is right when he says that for the average person, it is best to invest in the market index funds like S&P 500.

The main point against this investment type was that if the stock market is overvalued then it might not be a good idea to invest in index funds. Currently, it is overvalued.

You read about it in my other article –  ‘Is the stock market overvalued?‘.

Exchange-traded funds (ETFs)

The funds are a lot like Mutual funds. The difference is that they are traded publicly. In the book, it is mentioned that they have 3% fees. However, this is not entirely true. For example, I can invest in my bank‘s ETF without any fees.

The question is are they any good?

Robo-advisors

Recently Robo-advisors were introduced to the market where computer helps you invest according to your risk tolerance.

That downside is that they take 2.5% fees. Of course, this also does not guarantee any returns.

Charlie Munger‘s 4 rules

A lot of attention in the book is given to the 4 rules of Charlie Munger. Charlie and Warren Buffet uses these 4 principles for their own investing.

I believe it is worth knowing the rules as both of the investors are elite in what they do. This can help you create your own investment checklist.

Rule No 1. Being capable of understanding the business

At first, you should focus on 1 or 2 industries that you have knowledge of. Think of companies that you already have an opinion about. That‘s a great start.

This is called a circle of competence. You know about these industries more because of your personal experience.

You can do an exercise that would take around 15 minutes. A Venn diagram of competence requires you to draw 3 overlapping circles. In these 3 circles, you write what you are passionate about, what you vote for with your money, and where you make your money.

Venn diagram
Source: book ‘Invested

Everything that overlaps is your circle of competence. However, you then narrow it down to only 1 which would be your circle of competence for investing. This is one of the first things you should include in your investment checklist.

You choose it by eliminating everything from your list one by one. For example, if startups were in your circle of confidence you should eliminate it as after the IPO around 80% of the companies lose in value from their starting valuation.

Rule No 2. Business with intrinsic characteristics that gives a durable competitive advantage

A durable competitive advantage can also be called a moat. It protects businesses against competition and can even help them grow during recessions.

You want to protect your investments with companies that have a moat. Your investment checklist should definately include this part.

There are 5 (and a half) moats that can protect a business:

  1. Brand

It is considered a moat when you think of a product and you associate it with a company.

  • Switching

Switching is considered in cases when it is hard for a customer to switch to another brand. Usually, because they are used to it and there would be some learning curve to use another.

  • Network effect

When you have followers on Facebook it can be hard to transfer them to Twitter.

  • Toll bridge

When a company has a monopoly it is considered a toll bridge. This usually happens with the government’s intervention when it gives a lot of power to one company.

  • Secret

Companies with ‚secret‘ moat are considered drug development companies. It takes a very long time to develop drugs and they are protected by law for a lot of years.

  • Price

When a company can offer products at a lower price that others cannot compete with.

The big 4 numbers

As it can be hard to determine which companies have moats just by reading about them there are also some numbers in the company’s balance sheet that can tell you if the company has a moat or not. In total it is only 4 numbers that you need to check.

NumberWhere to find itDescription
Net income (Net profit or Net earning)Income statementIt shows a profit after all costs have been deducted.
Book value (Equity) + DividendsBook value can be found in the Balance sheet and dividends can be found in the Cash flow statement.This shows the value of a business if all of its assets were sold before any dividends were paid out.
Sales (Revenue)Income statementThis shows what the company earned from selling.
Operating cashCash flow statementThis shows the actual cash earned from the business operations.

You can find historic numbers in macrotrends.net instead of reviewing all the income statements one by one.

What you want to see in these 4 numbers is a 10% growth in each of them. However, tread lightly as they show the past and there might be some changes happening in the company that indicates that these numbers might change in the future.

After you see what are these growth rates you then have to take an educated guess about what is the growth rate of the company taking into account all the other things you find about it. It is called the Windage growth rate.

You should not simply make an average of the big 4 numbers. You can come up with this number after researching the company, what it does and what it is planning to do.

These 4 numbers should be noted in your investment checklist as well.

Rule No 3. Management with integrity and talent

When choosing a company you want it to be simple and easily managed so that any idiot could run it because one day an idiot will run it.

However, there are some criteria you can investigate the current management of the company and determine if the current CEO knows what he or she is doing and predict how long will they stay in their position.

  • Biography (do they have needed experience?)
  • Management style (how they run the company?)
  • Founder (Is the founder still managing the company?)
  • Board of directors (Who are they and how much impact do they do?)
  • Ownership (Does the CEO has his money on the line?)

Reading about the manager of the company should be included in your investment checklist.

Management numbers to check

After you do a background check you can also check some numbers to determine if the CEO knows what he or she is doing.

NumberFormulaWhere to find itDescription
Return on EquityReturn on Equity = Net income / by EquityNet income is found on the income statement. Equity – balance sheet.This number shows how well the managers spend our invested money. The drawback is that this number can be engineered by borrowing money. That is why we have to look into the return on invested capital.
Return on Invested CapitalReturn on Invested Capital = Net income / (Equity + Debt)Net income is found on the income statement. Equity – balance sheet.
Debt – balance sheet.
This shows us the same thing as Return on Equity but it also includes the debt that the company has. It is best if you see both of these numbers with an average of 15% growth or better for at least 10 years.
DebtYears to pay debt = Debt/Net IncomeNet income – income statement.
Debt – balance sheet.
Debt generally is bad and a lot of long-term debt can cause management to declare bankruptcy. We want to see a company be able to pay off its debt in 1 or 2 years with its earnings.  

To remember all of these things it is best to make yourself an investment checklist of what you need to check so you would not forget. You should not make a checklist so huge that you would need to research a company for a month but a simple and neat investment checklist can save you a lot of trouble.

Rule No 4. Buy at a price that gives a margin of safety

To buy a company you need to determine the price that makes sense, the one that seems to be on sale. That is called the margin of safety. This is the last thing that can protect you if you made a mistake in previous steps.

3 methods you should use to determine a share price

  • Ten Cap price (based on owners earnings)

Capitalization rate (ten cap for short) is a method that Warren Buffet uses. It means the money you receive for the money you own each year. And the ratio between them is the return on investment.

Buffer and Munger require that the average return rate would be at least 10%. That is why this method is called Ten Cap.

The math is simple here – you should multiply the owner’s earnings by ten. This is the price you should be paying for a company.

The downside of this method is that opportunity to buy a company at this price comes once in 30 years according to Phil Towns.

The formula for the owner’s earnings is:

Owners earnings = Net Income + Depreciation and Amortization + Net Charge: Accounts receivable + Net Charge: Accounts payable + income tax + Maintenance capital expenditures

  • Payback Time price (based on free cash flow)

This method is great for those who are buying to keep stock. It shows how many years it takes for the investment to pay for itself or in other words to double your money.

The Payback Time price is calculated by compounding Free cash flow by the Windage growth rate for 8 years.

You will have to sum all the compounded free cash flow in the 8 years period and the price you get is what you can pay for the company.

Both of the metrics in this formula cannot be found on the income statement, however, you can calculate them. The windage rate was explained before and the Free cash flow formula is much simpler than Owner’s earnings.

Free cash flow = Net cash flow from operating activities – Purchase of property and equipment – Any other capital expenditures for maintenance and growth

  • The margin of safety valuation (based on earnings)

This method focuses you evaluating what you would have to pay today for future earnings including the risk of getting that money in the future.

The margin of safety is quite hard to calculate so I will go step by step. First, these are the numbers that you will need:

  • Earning per share (EPS) – you can find this in the income statement.
  • Windage growth rate – I have mentioned this rate before and how to calculate it.
  • Windage Price-to-Earnings (P/E) ratio – is calculated by multiplying the Windage growth rate by 2 or by or using the highest P/E ratio from the last 10 years (You can find it anywhere on the internet). Use the lowest of the 2 numbers.
  • Minimum Acceptable Rate of Return (MARR) – as the name suggests you have to think of a number that is worthwhile for you for all the work you put into researching your investments. The book suggests using 15%.

That is all for the numbers you will need. However, there are 4 steps you need to do to calculate the margin of safety.

Step 1. Calculate Future 10-Year earnings per share = EPS x (1 + Windage growth rate) [Repeat 10 times]

Step 2. Calculate Future 10-Year Share Price = Future 10-Year earning per share x Windage P/E ratio (Or P/E ratio)

Step 3. Sticker price = Future 10-Year Share Price / 4. If you want to use a different number for MARR than 15% then you should use this formula: Sticker price = Future 10-Year Share price / (1.15) by the power of Years

Step 4. Calculate Margin of Safety buy price = Sticker price / 2

As you can see that calculation is quite long, yet simple. You can read the book ‚Invested‘ to see that examples of where this formula is used.

Sometimes you can get very different results from the 3 valuations mentioned above. It is because they calculate completely different things. However, in most cases, Payback Time Price gives you the most accurate valuation.

Ten Cap price shows you if you found a winner to earn 10 times your money and the Margin of Safety valuation gives you a conservative price.

You should include at least one of these 3 valuations in your investment checklist if not all of them.

Story of a company

One of the main things for a new investor is to learn about a company. You should not invest just because you think the company is good or you heard that a lot of people are buying it.

After you have learned the finances you have to conclude what you found in a story. What you want is to create a story of a company why it is amazing and why you want to own it.

To tell a story of a company first you need to understand it. You can ask a question like What do they do or How do they do it?

When building your investment checklist you should consider adding this point as well.

Create a 2-minute story about why it is a good investment

In your short story, you should include things like companies mission, moat, management, and price. Also include an event that has put the company on sale and how the company will turn it around.

Find arguments why the company will not reach its goals

For the main reasons to own the company find the reasons not to own it. After that try to debate with yourself why these arguments are incorrect.

Imagine this process as debates or preparation for a court.

Voting for a mission

One interesting take on investing is that you do not just invest to earn money – you also invest because you believe in what the company does.

It is like voting. You have a limited amount of money that you can diversify to other companies. When you invest in a company you give it your money and trust that the company will make sound decisions with it for the company and for others.

Expensive errors to your investment checklist

Phil Town included some things that he has lost his money in the past. When it comes to money it is best to learn from other’s mistakes.

Meaning

In this category, all the errors are about not evaluating all the risks and not finding enough information about the company from the start.

Moat

All the mistakes in this category are made by falsely identifying the moat and overestimating it. This can happen if you did not do enough research or if you miscalculated the big 4 numbers.

Management

If you fail you get a good feeling about the CEO or calculate management numbers incorrectly you get a false image of the management.

This can be avoided if you pick simple companies that anyone can run.

Pricing

Errors associated with pricing comes from overpaying for a stock by buying it too early or you did not correctly evaluate the stock price.

Practice shares

If you are new to investing it can be hard to start buying shares mentally or even technically if you are not familiar with the platform that you are buying shares from.

This is why when a company is getting near your buying price it can be a good idea to buy a small number of shares with money that you would not be stressed out if you lost but yet would feel bad if you did.

If you do this before investing it will be much easier to do it for real when the time comes.

I would consider this point optional for your investment checklist as it will not generate value for your investment directly. It would help you to prepare mentally instead.

Other suggestions from the book

This amazing book had some other useful suggestions. I will mention some of them.

  • Diversify your money between different industries

First, you should start with what you know best. However, when you learn you should expand and choose more industries to invest in. You can learn more about industries in my other article ‘Is the stock market overvalued?‘.

  • Passive-aggressive strategy

Avoid buying everything that is overpriced. However, if the price is right start buying aggressively. As Warren Buffet said be fearful when others are greedy and be aggressive when others are fearful.

  • Do not spend more than 10% of your money on one stock

When investing you should put most of your money into the companies that you believe in the most. However, it should not be more than 10%.

  • Set up a whishlist

Make a table of companies that you have reviewed and what companies you want to buy. Also, include a short story of a few points about why you want to buy it and at what price.

Moreover, include a priority with each company in which you would buy companies if more than one company became on sale. You sort them by the order that you believe in the company.

  • Buy in trenches

If an event happens that puts the company on sale then avoid putting all the money in it at once. Nobody can predict when the company has reached its peak or bottom. So, buying it in slices helps you when the company’s price will go beyond your buying price.

By doing this you will avoid getting angry at yourself for not timing your purchase perfectly and earn even more.

  • Reducing your basis

When your company grows take out your starting investment, so that if anything happens at least you made your money back.

  • Dividends

Who wouldn‘t want a cash flow coming to you every year? Well, there are people who invest solely for dividends. However, beware of the company that misses or reduces its dividends as the majority of people would see this is breaking their trust.

Because of that people start selling stock and then its price starts to drop. It is much harder to get that trust back once it was broken.

You should always look for companies that pay dividends without fail or even increased them for at least 10 years.

  • Buybacks

Buybacks are a great sign for stock owners because once the stocks are bought back your share value instantly increases as there are fewer shares.

  • When to sell?

The only time you would want to sell a company is when the story of the company changes and it does not seem like a good investment.

Checklist for further learning

Don’t miss new articles by subscribing!

Is The Stock Market Overvalued?

Is the stock market overvalued

In this article I will try to answer the question – is the stock market overvalued and teach you how can you check this yourself. 

According to a great book ‘Invested‘ by Danielle Town and Phil Town you only need Shiller P/E Ratio and Buffet Indicator to see if the stock market is overvalued. 

However, I included all the other indicators that I know of if you wanted a second opinion.

Shiller P/E Ratio

Shiller P/E ratio
Source: multpl.com

Shiller P/E Ratio = Share price / (10-year average inflation – Adjusted earnings)

Shiller’s P/E ratio is different from other indicators because it includes 10-year average inflation and cyclically adjusted price to earnings. 

The current Shiller P/E Ratio is 27.73. Its mean is 16.99, median – is 15.90. Right now it is close to the highest it ever was.

Right now it is the fourth time this ratio has increased by over 25 and every other time market crashed a lot. However, this indicator does not tell us when the market will crash. It might be a week, 2 years, or even 3 years, but it will crash.

If you wish to know more about this ratio you can read a book by Robert Shiller called ‘Irrational Exuberance‘.

Buffett Indicator

Buffet Indicator
Source: Currentmarketvaluation.com

Buffet indicator = Stock market cap / Nation‘s GDP

The buffet indicator is the ratio between the market as a whole and the national revenue. This is one of the best ratios you can look into if you want to know where the market stands at any given moment.

  • Buffett Indicator is 158% and according to the exponential trendline, 128% would be considered to be fairly valued. 
  • According to Phil Town if the value is around 60% then the market is undervalued and if it is over 100% it is overvalued.
  • Warren Buffet himself said that if the indicator is near 200% the market is highly overvalued.

According to this ratio, the market was overvalued for 10 years now. In 2009 the Federal Reserve Bank had an intervention of 4 trillion US dollars that stopped the crash from it being worse. Also, interest rates were lowered to 0. 

I believe that Warren Buffet is not holding to his cash for no reason. At the moment it is hard to find good investments. However, it is possible.

S&P 500 P/E Ratio

S&P 500 P/E ratio
Source: multpl.com

P/E ratio is calculated by this formula – P/E Ratio = Share price / Earning per share (EPS)

We need to check the historic average P/E ratio to the current P/E ratio of the market.

Currently, S&P 500 P/E ratio is 19.71, the mean is 15.99 and the median is 14.91. This suggests that the stock market is overvalued.

Analysts do not like this metric as according to them the value of the market keeps rising, so it does not show the full picture. However, analysts try to find all the reasons to prove that the market is priced fairly.

S&P 500 Earning Yield

S&P 500 Earning yield
Source: multpl.com

Earning yield = Earning per share (EPS) / Share price

This is an inverse ratio to the S&P500 P/E ratio. Earning yield is 5.08%, its mean is 7.28% and the median is 6.71%. The less Earning yield is the more the market is overvalued.

This means that if you invest 100 USD in S&P500 you could expect to receive 5 USD annually from your investment.

This ratio is not conclusive it simply supports the S&P500 P/E ratio. However, it shows that the market is overvalued, but it has a trend to get back to normal levels.

S&P 500 Dividend Yield

S&P 500 Dividend yield
Source: multpl.com

Dividend yield = Annual dividend / Share price

The dividend yield right now is 1.70%. Its mean is 4.27% and the median is 4.23%. This indicates that the market is overvalued at the moment.

When stock prices rise it tends that dividends do not rise as fast. If you want to invest in S&P500 for its dividends then it is the worst moment in history to do that. This ratio was lower only in the 2000 crisis.

S&P 500 Mean Reversion

S&P 500 mean reversion
Source: currentmarketvaluation.com

This ratio refers to a stock‘s price and that it will fluctuate around its average over the long term. So, if the market is above the trend it will fall below the trend and if it is below the trend line then it will rise in the future.

According to the historic trendline with added expected growth S&P500 is currently 27% above the trend. So, it is overvalued at the moment.

Interest Rates

US interest rate
Source: tradingeconomics.com

The current United States Fed Funds Rate is 4.4%. It has recently been increased a few times. 

This means that the US government decided to make it more expensive to borrow money and by that decrease spending. They did this to fight high inflation rates. Therefore, the US market will stop growing as much and return to a more sustainable growth rate.

This indicates that we should not expect high growth rates for the S&P 500 as we saw for the last couple of years. There are some speculations that interest rates will rise above 5% next year in the US. Of this, the market should slow down even more.

Bond Returns

US Bond returns
Source: tradingeconomics.com

The US bond returns started rising recently to 3.8391%. In the past year, it has increased by 2.333%. We have not seen such a high rate since the 2008 market crash. 

This is very concerning as bond returns get higher it will be a better (and safer) investment option than the stock market.

When this happens investors tend to sell their stocks and go to the bonds. Therefore, the stock market will decrease in value as the money from it will be pulled out by the investors who would find alternative investment options.

Right now we are going there and this could be one of the reasons that the market will crash as some people leaving the stock market will cause others to see falling prices and because of fear, they would also retrieve their money from the investments crashing the market, even more, creating the snowball effect.

Yield Curve Inversion

US Yield curve inversion
Source: ustreasuryyieldcurve.com

In this table, you can see the difference in interest rates between different U.S. Treasury bond yields.

Normally you would see short-term bonds have lower yields than long-term bonds. However, if people expect a stock market crash to happen you can see (like right now) people buying bonds.

At the start of this year bond yield was 2.17% and right now it is 3.98%.

This graph that it is right is a bad sign for the economy and most likely will lead to a bad market crash in less than 2 years.

Market Capitalization to GDP Ratio

Market capitalization to GDP ratio
Source: Worldbank.org

Currently, the whole market capitalization to GDP ratio is 133.2%. However, the ratio for the US is skyrocketing at 193.3%.

If the ratio is below 70% then the market is undervalued. If it is above 125% then it is overvalued. This is very similar to Buffer Indicator except for this count for the whole market.

According to the numbers the market is as overvalued as it can be in the US. By this, we could expect a crash.

Sector S&P 500 P/E Ratios and Shiller P/E Ratios

Shiller P/E ratio by sectors
Data source: gurufocus.com

In the graph above you can see averages from the last 13 years and current Shiller P/E ratios by each sector.

By this, you can see that the Energy sector is highly overvalued and you should avoid it.

However, the Communications services sector is highly undervalued.

When you look at the whole market you see that it is overvalued. However, there are 11 main sectors by which you can make a closer look. As it might be a bad idea to invest in index funds at the moment you can probably still find some good investment opportunities by looking at each sector and looking at companies one by one.

P/E ratio by sectors
Data source: gurufocus.com

In the graph above you can see the Regular P/E ratio at the moment and the average from the last 13 years. 

Again like with the Shiller P/E ratio you can see that the Energy sector is overvalued.

However, the Communication Services sector is less undervalued than Shiller P/E showed us and in fact, the Basic Materials sector might be the one undervalued.

You can use both of these graphs to guide you in the right direction. However, you should look into each company individually. It is possible that you would find some great investment opportunities in other sectors as well.

Is The Stock Market Overvalued?

To put it simply – yes it is very much overvalued and it probably will crash in less than 2 years according to different ratios.

What you should do with this information? Well, it might be a good idea to stock up on cash or choose a different investment idea than to invest in stock market indexes like S&P500.

By looking closer into each section you can see that not all sectors are overvalued at the moment so you might be able to find some stocks that currently are selling at fair prices.

Also, you could look into my alternative investment section or even keep your saving in cash to wait for amazing investment opportunities when the market will crash.

If you want to learn more you can check stablebread.com article.

Conclusion

We answered the question – is the stock market overvalued and the answer is a hard yes. Especially the Energy sector and we can expect a crash soon.

In general, you would not need to look into all these ratios that were mentioned in this article. It is more than enough for most of us to check 1 or 2 ratios to get the picture.

However, I think it is good to know that they are out there and to know how to use them.

According to the book ‘Invested‘ you only need 2 ratios that are very easy to look up and track if you are interested in what current condition the stock market is currently in.

Generally, you can look up only the Shiller P/E ratio which should be around 17 for the market to be priced fairly, or to Buffet Indicator which should be below 100%. If these ratios are higher than that then yes, the market is overvalued.

Don’t miss new articles by subscribing!